Concrete Driveway Resurface vs Replace: What’s Better When?
drivewaygeek.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com
“Concrete Driveway Resurface vs Replace” is a dilemma that homeowners are bound to face as their concrete driveway deteriorates with age.
The dilemma has no easy solutions and appears to be complicated.
While the actual recommendation will depend on several factors, here is what, in a nutshell, helps you make the right choice.
Concrete Driveway Resurface vs Replace: Quick Comparison
| Factor | Resurface | Replace |
|---|---|---|
| Suitable Conditions | Minor surface issues | Severe damage and structural concerns |
| Cost | Budget-friendly | Higher upfront cost, but potential long-term savings |
| Environmental Impact | Less material used | Potential for sustainable practices in construction |
| Duration | Faster process | Longer timeline |
| Durability | Short-term solution | Long-term solution |
| Property Disruption | Minimal | Significant |
Concrete Driveway Resurfacing
Concrete driveway resurfacing is a process that involves applying a new layer on top of the existing concrete surface that has worn out and is, generally speaking, not in good condition.
Concrete driveway resurfacing is an excellent choice when your driveway has minor surface issues like cracks, stains, or small irregularities. By resurfacing, you can give your driveway a fresh look without ripping it out entirely.
When to Resurface?
If your driveway displays signs of surface damage but still maintains its structural integrity, resurfacing can work wonders. Those pesky cracks and stains can be smoothed over, giving your driveway a new lease on life.
Concrete Driveway Replacement
Concrete driveway replacement, on the other hand, means removing the old concrete and installing an entirely new driveway. This option becomes necessary when your existing driveway has severe damage, compromising its stability and strength.
When to Replace?
When your driveway exhibits extensive cracks, sinking, or foundation issues, it’s time for a full replacement. A replacement provides an opportunity to build a brand new, sturdy driveway that will last for years to come.
Concrete Driveway Resurface vs Replace: Cost Comparison
Now, let’s talk dollars and cents. Resurfacing is generally more budget-friendly than replacement since it requires less material and labor.
However, keep in mind that resurfacing might not be a long-term fix, and you may need to repeat it every 5 – 10 years, depending on the resurfacing material used.
On the other hand, while a full replacement may cost more upfront, it offers greater durability and can be a cost-effective option in the long run due to fewer repairs.
Environmental Impact
If you are environmentally conscious, then opting for concrete driveway resurfacing, such as rubber coating, is certainly more responsible. When it comes to the environment, resurfacing is more eco-friendly since it uses fewer resources).
But if your concrete has structurally deteriorated or has been severely damaged by severe ground movement, the only sensible option is to replace.
In this situation, a well-planned replacement can incorporate sustainable practices, such as recycling the old concrete.
Pros and Cons of Resurfacing a Concrete Driveway
Pros:
- Cost-effective: Resurfacing is generally more budget-friendly than replacement.
- Improved Appearance: It can give your driveway a fresh, renewed look.
- Faster Process: Resurfacing takes less time than a complete replacement.
- Minimal Disruption: There is less disruption to your property during the resurfacing process.
Cons:
- Temporary Fix: Resurfacing might not address underlying issues and may require subsequent resurfacing.
- Limited to Surface Issues: Resurfacing won’t fix structural problems or extensive damage.
Pros and Cons of Replacing a Concrete Driveway
Pros:
- Long-term Solution: A full replacement provides a new, durable driveway that lasts for years.
- Structural Integrity: It addresses severe issues, like sinking or extensive cracking.
- Increased Property Value: A well-constructed driveway can boost your property’s value.
Cons:
- Higher Cost: Replacement is more expensive due to demolition costs, disposal costs in addition to new cost of materials and labor.
- Longer Timeline: It takes more time to complete a full replacement compared to resurfacing.
- Disruption to Property: The process involves more significant disruption during construction.
Concrete Driveway Resurface vs Replace: Pros & Cons
| Pros of Resurfacing | Cons of Resurfacing |
|---|---|
| Cost-effective: Budget-friendly option | Temporary Fix: May require subsequent resurfacing |
| Improved Appearance: Fresh, renewed look | Limited to Surface Issues, won’t fix structural problems |
| Faster Process: Saves time | |
| Minimal Disruption: Less property disruption during resurfacing |
| Pros of Replacement | Cons of Replacement |
|---|---|
| Long-term Solution: Durable, lasting driveway | Higher Cost: Includes demolition, disposal, materials, and labor |
| Structural Integrity: Addresses severe issues | Longer Timeline: Takes more time to complete |
| Increased Property Value: Boosts property value | Disruption to Property: Involves significant disruption during construction |
Resurface or Replace: How to Decide?
Deciding whether to resurface or replace your concrete driveway can be a challenging task. Here are some key factors to consider:
- Extent of Damage: Assess the severity of cracks, sinking, and other issues. Minor surface problems can easily be resolved through resurfacing, while extensive damage may require a full replacement.
- Structural Integrity: Consider the overall condition and stability of your driveway. If the foundation is compromised, replacement will be the safer and better choice.
- Long-Term Goals: Think about how long you plan to stay in your property. If you’re looking for a more permanent solution, replacement might be the better option.
- Budget: Evaluate your budget and determine what you can afford. Resurfacing is typically more cost-effective, but a replacement offers long-term value.
- Environmental Impact: If sustainability is a priority, consider the eco-friendliness of each option and explore sustainable practices in construction.
If you are unsure about the structural integrity of your concrete driveway, consult a reputed contractor or structural engineer in your area.
Kindly also check the local codes. Replacement will certainly require a building permit.
EXPERT TIP: Resurfacing and resealing will usually get the job done unless your concrete driveway’s structural integrity is in question.
RECOMMENDED PRODUCTS
The Best Sealers for Your Concrete Driveway or Patio
A topical sealer is essential for protecting concrete surfaces from water permeation that can damage the concrete from within and compromise its lifespan.
I highly recommend Foundation Armor Concrete Sealers. Pick the one that best meets your aesthetic and application preference.
Thank you very much for reading this post. I do hope you found it informative and helpful.
